The meal supplement and replacement craze have shown no signs of slowing. It is an appealing idea to drink a shake, losing weight, and stay healthy. The market size is expected to grow to over 12 billion by 2020.

With several choices on the market, it’s hard to find the right supplement. Let’s dissect two companies providing a range of shakes to help you make the best choice for best results.

Arbonne Shakes VS Shakeology

Arbonne Shakes VS Shakeology

Arbonne Shakes and Shakeology are two premium meal replacement/supplement providers on the market.

Arbonne Shakes are but a small part of the multi-product Arbonne enterprise. Their plant-based shakes are part of their Arbonne Essentials line.

Arbonne intends to bring foundational nutrition through their shakes in an easily accessible way. Their shakes are designed to support a healthy lifestyle, improving health and weight loss.

Shakeology is a range of shakes created by the famous Beachbody company. Beachbody CEO, Mr. Carl Daikeler set out to make a shake that was high quality. It would contain carefully sourced ingredients that could help fill dietary gaps while helping customers lose weight. Since its creation in 2009, it has sold millions in product and has built a loyal following.

Both shakes are sold through Multi-Level Marketing Programs, where shakeology coaches or Arbonne consultants are incentivized to sell these products and also conn. Most consumers dislike MLM Programs, but this has not deterred the products from being successful.

Let us take a look at what you can expect from both brands.

Nutritional Benefits

Arbonne shakes are 160 calorie dense supplements that contain an impressive 20g protein. These shakes boast zero cholesterol, saturated fats, and trans fats.

With 15 grams of carbs, 9 grams of sugar, and up to 2 grams of dietary fiber, Arbonne aim is to provide a balanced shake. There is a high sodium content at 480 mg, which is concerning.

Shakeology nutrition label has the benefits you expect in a supplement with up to 160 calories per serving. With 2 grams of fat as well as 11 grams of sugar and 17 grams of carbohydrates, it ticks all the nutritional boxes, except sugar, which can always be lower.

In a shakeology shake, you get an excellent 17 grams of quality protein. There is also 95 mg sodium and 10mg cholesterol.

While Arbonne may have a higher protein count, lower calorie, and sugar count than shakeology, it is high sodium content is a red flag.

Ingredients Used

Arbonne is based on pea protein, a cleaner, healthier protein source. There’s also brown rice protein and cranberry protein.

Sources of A, C, D, and E vitamins along with traces of magnesium, zinc, CoQ10, and ginseng. There are other additives that you should not associate with a green’ company like corn starch, xanthan gum, sunflower oil, and cane sugar.

The protein blend in shakeology is made of whey, chia, and flaxseed, along with other ingredients. In addition to protein, shakeology prides itself on adding organic superfoods’ to enhance the benefits of the shake. You can find green tea, Acerola Cherry, goji berry, and Vitamins A, C, and E. A big concern is the labeling of their whey as highest commercial-grade and not organic or “grass-fed which may mean unnecessary additives.

This is really a choice of what’s important to the consumer; a natural protein source or natural additives. Each brand has its pros and cons.


Arbonne is cost-effective for 30 servings at close to USD 80. This works out to about USD2.00 per serving. Arbonne essentials are one of the cheaper meal supplement brands on the market that contains green ingredients.

The shakeology line is more expensive at USD129.95 for a 30 serving bag or 24 on the go packets. This works out to be almost USD4.30 per serving. With the host of alternatives on the market, with arguably better quality protein, there is little to justify the price.


Arbonne has a small suite of flavors in Chai as well as Chocolate, and Vanilla. The feedback from customers that it has a smooth flavor, whether with milk or water.

Shakeology has a range of flavors to choose from, including Strawberry, Chocolate, Vanilla, Greenberry, Vegan-Tropical Strawberry, and Cafe Latte. General shakeology reviews from customers state that flavors are not intense and adding ingredients like milk or berries enhances the flavor.

Value-Added Incentives

One of shakeology’s biggest incentives is the coaching access that comes with it. You have access to a group of coaches that can help keep you motivated and accountable. They intend to build a community around the product, and that’s an added benefit. The Beachbody team also offers a refund after 30 days if you don’t like it. This is honored even if the bag is empty. These added value items may account for the higher price point.

Arbonne does not have a team of coaches but it does have extensive resources available to its customers. For example, the 30 Days to Healthy-Living and Beyond-Set and Support-Guide is a detailed guide on food choices, supplements, and nutrition facts to help you change your lifestyle within 30 Days.


Meal replacements should be analyzed with care. Decide what’s most important for you, research the ingredients and choose the best. In our arbonne shakes VS shakeology assessment, we show that each brand has its strengths and weaknesses.

Arbonne positions itself as a meal replacement while Shakeology does as a meal supplement. This should also be considered when choosing the best for your weight loss or dietary needs.

About The Author

Related Posts